Need a little “R and R?” Try jury duty…

The Millen Brothers/Abraham Faber murder/robbery trial was one of the most sensational criminal cases of the 1930’s, if not of the 20th century. The basic facts of the trial are related in my book and in shorter form in a post from last June entitled “An Execution in Charlestown.”

The trial of the three men accused of robbing a Needham bank and killing two policemen began in April, 1934, just a few months after the shocking crime. The jury was sequestered, and just as in the Sacco/Vanzetti trial the previous decade, they were lodged in the court house, sleeping on cots in one of the larger, unused court rooms. Their shower facilities were in the basement of the jail in which the accused were being held.

Perhaps the intensity of the trial testimony and the less than four-star accommodations prompted court officials to provide the men with a wide variety of leisure activities when the trial was not in session. These activities were recorded in some detail by Juror #11, foreman Ted Davis of Norwood, who had the “diary” privately printed after the trial was over. Along with the trip to Nauset Beach as described above and pictured below, other jury excursions and entertainments included:

* 3 Red Sox games and 1 Braves game
* A bus tour of the Mohawk Trail
* Taking in a polo match at the Dedham Polo Club
* Bowling, horseshoes, sing-alongs, long walks around Dedham
* Trips to Martha’s Vineyard, the Peabody Museum, Cohasset, Scituate and Plymouth

On June 9 the jury returned a verdict of guilty and, according to Davis’ diary “made for home as quickly as possible.” Jury Foreman Davis had an extra treat during his 2 month stint when he was allowed to see his new-born daughter in the hospital (accompanied by two Deputy Sheriffs) on May 29.

In the photographs below, Deputy Sheriff Norris Pinault (in white shirt) cavorts with jurors at Nauset Beach in Orleans. Thanks to Norris Shook, grandson of Deputy Pinault for providing me with the photos, the news article, and the diary kept by Ted Davis.

Explore posts in the same categories: History/Mystery

5 Comments on “Need a little “R and R?” Try jury duty…”

  1. Wow! What a story. It makes me wonder what their contemporaries do! Who created the two photographs?


    • Jim Parr Says:

      The photos came from Deputy Sheriff Pinault’s personal album, so I’m not sure who took them. You can still see the glue marks on the back (probably that mucilage stuff).


  2. Norris Shook Says:

    Hi Jim,

    The pictures look nice!

    I do not know where my grandfather got the photos, but I am glad that you are able to share them with the public. They are a bit of history that needs to be out there for everyone to see.

    Look forward to seeing the book about the trial.



  3. W. Shook Says:

    I am Norris Shook’s Father and can say that “Norrie” Pinault was quite a fellow and an important part of the history of the South Shore in the 1930’s and ’40’s.
    Bill Shook


  4. Hello to every one, it’s in fact a nice for me to visit this website, it consists of priceless Information.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: